Roof ROI Calculator
A new roof does not pay for itself. Asphalt recoups about 61% at resale — the best of any roofing material — and metal only around 49%. The real return is defensive: a failing roof kills a sale, and water damage costs far more than the roof did.
Your Roof Investment
Material
Your Roof ROI
Estimated value recouped at resale
Mid range
You're browsing as a guest — download, print and share all work. to save this project.
What's included
- Installation labor
- Permit
- Waste factor (%)
- Sales tax
Tax applies to materials only — labor on a real-property improvement is untaxed in most states. Check your local rate.
Warranty · Lifespan · Maintenance
Material quantities
Includes your % waste factor
| Roofing squares | |
| Shingle bundles | |
| Underlayment rolls | |
| Roofing nails | |
| Ridge cap | |
| Drip edge |
Project timeline
Typical for squares
Estimate confidence
Confidence reflects what we actually know about your inputs — whether you measured or estimated, how complex your roof is, and whether we hold labor data for your state. It is not a fabricated percentage.Sources: BLS state wage data · tracked material pricing · your measurements · Methodology
What to do next
Already have a contractor's quote?
We'll grade it against this estimate and flag the terms that cost homeowners money.
How accurate does this estimate look?
Your feedback helps improve future estimates.
/250
Thank you!
Your feedback helps improve CostSquared estimates for other homeowners.
Estimates are planning ranges, not quotes. Read our methodology.
Save Your Project
Create a free CostSquared account to save this estimate and access it anytime.
- Save unlimited estimates
- Compare multiple projects
- Download PDF reports
- Track your renovation costs
You can still download, print and share your estimate.
How we calculated your estimate
We apply published cost-versus-value recoup rates by material to your project cost. These rates reflect what comparable homes actually achieve at resale — not what a contractor tells you your roof is "worth".
Labor rates derive from published BLS occupational wage data. Read the full methodology →
Quick cost summary
Asphalt recoup
61%
The highest of any roofing material
Tile recoup
55%
Long life, but a niche buyer pool
Slate recoup
53%
Premium material, premium cost
Metal recoup
49%
Costs the most, returns the least proportionally
Factors that affect the cost
How soon you sell
A roof replaced the year you sell recoups most. One replaced ten years ago is simply "an old roof" again.
Material choice
Counter-intuitively, the cheapest material returns the highest percentage. Buyers expect asphalt and will not pay a premium for metal.
Local market
In areas where every house has a tile roof, tile is expected and returns better. Distinctiveness cuts both ways.
Condition of the old roof
The real return is avoiding a failed sale. Buyers and their inspectors treat a failing roof as a reason to walk or to demand a large concession.
Ways to save money
Don't over-improve before selling
If you are selling next year, a premium metal roof is money you will not get back. Buyers expect a sound roof, not an exceptional one.
Do replace a failing roof before listing
A roof at the end of its life will cost you more in negotiation than the replacement would have cost you outright — buyers discount aggressively for uncertainty.
Common mistakes to avoid
Treating a roof as an investment
It is not one. It is maintenance. Framing it as an investment leads people to over-spend on materials that will not return the premium.
Assuming the most expensive roof adds the most value
Metal costs the most and recoups the least, proportionally. The relationship between cost and resale value is not linear.
Frequently asked questions
Yes, but it does not pay for itself. A new asphalt roof recoups around 61% of its cost at resale, the highest of any material. The bigger value is defensive — it removes a major buyer objection.
Asphalt, at roughly 61%. Counter-intuitively, the more expensive materials recoup a lower percentage — metal returns about 49%, despite costing two to three times as much.
If it is at the end of its life, yes. Buyers and inspectors discount aggressively for a failing roof — usually by more than the replacement would have cost you.
No, and framing it that way leads to bad decisions. A roof is maintenance. Its return is preventing water damage and preserving your ability to sell, not appreciating in value.
The value fades as the roof ages. A roof replaced the year you sell counts for a great deal; one replaced fifteen years ago counts for very little.
Related calculators
Related cost guides
Got a quote from a contractor?
Paste it into the Quote Decoder and we'll grade it against the fair range for your roof.